While the missiles and drones continue to fly
around the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden, US policy-makers are now working
methodically to understand the impacts on the broader economy and thinking
about crafting policies to deal with potential disruptions.
This week, the US House of Representatives,
Subcommittee on Coast Guard and Maritime Transportation- part of the wider
reaching Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, held a session titled “Menace on the Red Sea:
Securing Shipping Against Threats in the Red Sea” The list of witnesses
included Bud Darr, who handles “Maritime Policy and Governmental Affairs”
at MSC, which he was quick
to note is a member of the World Shipping Council, which represents nearly all
of the liners with vessels calling at US ports.
In his remarks, Darr noted that initial attacks
were aimed at vessels with an Israeli connection, but the situation had now
evolved to one where “the Houthi’s targeting
has become so attenuated from Israeli interests that it is indiscriminate,
placing all commercial vessels transiting the Southern Red Sea and Gulf of Aden
in the vicinity of Yemen at risk of being attacked.”
Speaking about MSC’s reaction, which he described
as “diverting services that would typically transit the Red Sea and the Suez
Canal around the Cape of Good Hope (CGH), until we are confident the security
situation is safe enough to have our seafarers return to the Red Sea”. Darr, a
veteran of the US Navy and US Coast Guard, asserted that: “The Red Sea security
situation has required MSC to re-wire its entire global network.”
A concern in the hearings, which also included
testimony from the cargo side- as represented by the National Retail
Federation, Darr honed on in the elephant in the room- the potential economic
impacts of these “re-wired” shipping patterns across the broader supply chain.
Indeed, the pandemic induced disruptions (circa 2021 into early 2022), and
disruptions at Panama, were mentioned by the Subcommittee’s Chairperson,
Congressman Dan Webster (Republican representing central Florida) noted: “We
saw firsthand during the pandemic what a significant supply chain crisis can do
to the global economy, and we must not let it happen again.”
In his testimony, Darr pointed to MSC (and
presumably other liner carriers) commitments to “serving the international
trade of the United States, and our adaptability and resiliency to continue to
move maritime commerce for importers and exporters across the world’s oceans
despite the current geopolitical challenges.”
Speaking about MSC’s position as the “largest fleet
in the world, with some 800 container ships, with a capacity exceeding 4
million teu”, he expressed a view, “that if we can continue to access US
ports uninterrupted, we have sufficient assets and capacity for the foreseeable
future to ensure US importers and exporters access to global markets.” Importantly,
Darr was quick to distinguish the present logistical snafus from the situation
in 2021, with vessels anchored in San Pedro Bay, telling Congressman Webster’s
panel: “the present situation is unique and distinct from the situation we
faced during the pandemic where the congestion was caused by US land-based
logistics being overwhelmed by unprecedented import demand.”