The proposal aims to address the high costs,
operational disruption and limited availability
of specialist resources associated with current measurement methods
The IMO’s Revised Guidelines for the Reduction of
Underwater Radiated Noise from Shipping (MEPC.1/Circ.906/Rev.1), which entered
into effect in October 2023, identify direct measurement as the preferred
method for establishing a ship’s URN baseline. Such measurements are also
normally required for classification society quiet ship notations. The
guidelines are currently in an experience-building phase, which MEPC 84 agreed
in principle to extend until the end of 2028, subject to confirmation at MEPC
85. According to the joint IMO
submission MEPC 85/9/2, dedicated URN measurement trials typically cost between
$30,000 and $50,000 per vessel. However, when vessel diversion, operational
disruption and lost revenue are included, the overall cost can increase to
between $40,000 and $250,000 per ship.
For a global fleet of approximately 100,000 vessels, conducting a single
round of baseline measurements could therefore cost an estimated $4 billion to
$25 billion. The organizations also
highlight significant capacity constraints, estimating that existing specialist
resources can support only around 50 dedicated trials annually. As URN emissions can change over time due
to factors such as propeller damage, hull condition or the installation of
energy efficiency technologies, repeated measurements may be necessary to
assess whether noise-reduction measures remain effective. To address these challenges, the
organizations propose establishing autonomous URN measurement facilities near
major shipping chokepoints, enabling vessels to undergo measurements during
normal operations without requiring dedicated sea trials. Potential locations identified in the
submission include approaches to the Suez and Panama Canals, the Strait of
Gibraltar, the Malacca Strait, the Taiwan Strait and the English Channel. Similar
facilities have already operated in locations including Vancouver, Canada’s St.
Lawrence Estuary and Genoa, Italy, providing experience that could support the
development of a wider measurement network.
The submission estimates that a network
of five autonomous facilities could require:
Capital investment: Approximately $0.8 million to $1.8 million. Annual
operating costs: Approximately $0.7 million to $1.4 million. Cost
allocation per vessel: Less than $20 in capital costs and $15 annually
in operating costs, assuming a global fleet of 100,000 ships. Data
verification and reporting: Approximately $4,424 per ship, based on
experience from the Genoa facility. Implementation timeline: Around
four years, including the development of an international measurement standard. These are preliminary estimates rather
than confirmed implementation costs. The organizations acknowledge that actual
expenses will depend on facility specifications, operating conditions and the
development of common measurement standards.
A central element of the proposal is the development of an ISO standard
for what the organizations describe as “Measurement of Opportunity.” The standard would establish common
technical and operational requirements for autonomous facilities, ensuring
measurements are sufficiently accurate and consistent to support quiet ship
class notations and comparisons of vessel noise emissions over time. The submission notes that existing
autonomous measurement facilities have not been developed under a common
standard, making it difficult to compare results obtained at different
locations. A standardized network
could allow ships operating on irregular routes to establish reliable URN
baselines and monitor changes in emissions using measurements from multiple
facilities. However, the
organizations acknowledge that such a network would not provide universal
coverage, particularly for vessels operating exclusively on short-sea routes. Alternative technologies, including onboard
measurement systems, drone-deployed sensors and predictive modeling, may
therefore be needed to supplement the proposed facilities.