The 35,000-ton USS
Defiant with the A1B nuclear reactor would have an unlimited range, allowing it
to sail for longer periods across the Indo-Pacific while generating electricity
needed to operate its advanced weapons and sensor systems. However, the project is riddled with
supply chain issues and other difficulties like a shortage of manpower.
U.S has just two shipyards
which are fit to build vessels with a nuclear reactor, which is a major issue
for the Navy in expanding its fleet to meet future naval defence
requirements. Huntington Ingalls
Industries (HII) Newport News is the only facility capable of building nuclear-powered
ships, and it is already struggling with delays and increasing costs on the
Gerald R. Ford-class aircraft carrier program.
On the other hand, General Dynamics Electric Boat mainly builds
submarines with a focus on high-priority attack and ballistic missile boats.
Hence, there are no alternative shipyards for additional nuclear-surface
combatants. The government is concerned
that if it adds another major demand, it would divert the reactor parts and workforce
from the Ford-class carrier project, the Columbia-class ballistic missile
submarines, and Virginia-class attack submarines. It would also affect the AUKUS agreement by
placing burdens on the main industrial assets, such as already-burdened dockyards, reactor vendor BWX Technologies, and the limited
workforce which is tasked with delivering Virginia-class submarines on
schedule.
U.S manufactures its
reactors on its own, but it depends on the U.S reactor design pedigree and a
limited and non-replenishable stockpile of Highly Enriched Uranium (HEU), over
50% of which originates from the US.
Hence, the decision to make Trump-class battleships, powered by nuclear
energy, has led to criticism around the project and raised concerns about
construction timelines. Critics have
argued that the 15-battleship goal is feasible for a fleet which has not been
projected to hit 355 ships until FY2040. Experts also said that the project
could be cancelled by the future government due to these issues.