The full shipping abatement cost curve data pack
containing carbon prices, added shipping fee estimates and alternative fuel costs
is available to Premium Energy
Transition and Decarbonistaion
subscribers. Users can now adjust support for each pathway individually
and see the effect on the required CO₂ price and added shipping cost.In the
chart below, CRU has applied an 80% reduction to each pathway’s incremental
vessel CAPEX for a consistent comparison (n.b. this is an upper-bound test
rather than an assumption that every pathway would receive the same award).
The results show that e-methanol and green ammonia remain unchanged as
the two highest-cost options, mostly as these are fuel OPEX-driven. The average
added shipping costs fall by just 4% and 15%, respectively, despite up to 80%
CAPEX support for vessel upgrades. That is, CAPEX support does nothing to
reduce the cost of the fuel used and only impacts the retrofit that allows the
alternative fuel to be used.Lower down the ranking, CAPEX support is more
influential, driving sharper declines especially with technologies such as
electrification, Fossil LNG switching and CCS, as upfront capital makes up a
larger share of their total costs, as shown in Part
2 of our insight series. Exposure to the
additional need for HFO to run the capture process limits the impact of CAPEX
support on the CCS pathway despite it being capital-intensive.Existing support
frameworks reinforce CRU’s model results. Direct vessel grants can be
represented within CRU’s framework where they reduce eligible onboard
incremental CAPEX. However, many programmes are competitive, first-of-a-kind
demonstrations, capped at project level or divided between vessel and
infrastructure expenditure. A published maximum therefore provides an
upper-bound sensitivity, not an expected effective support rate.To test
real-world sensitivity, we have looked at Norway’s Enova ammonia and
battery-electric programmes and tested against CRU’s modelling basis, with
Europe as a proxy at 2030 costs. Enova is a Norwegian state-owned enterprise
that works to promote energy efficiency, renewable energy and climate-smart
solutions. Enova’s
ammonia programme can cover up to 80% of approved additional vessel
costs, capped at €30 M per project. The next application deadline is 5 March
2027. Placed against CRU’s modelling, this implies a 16% reduction in the
carbon price required to incentivise green ammonia switching in shipping from
~$855 to ~$722 /tCO₂.Additionally, Enova’s
battery-electric programme specifically
illustrates why clients must also test funding caps. It offers up to 80% of
approved incremental vessel costs, but limits support to NOK100 M per vessel –
necessary charging infrastructure can receive separate support of up to 60%.
Against CRU’s ~$20.2 M incremental CAPEX for the battery case, the NOK100 M
vessel cap is equivalent to roughly $10.4 M at an exchange rate of NOK9.66 /$.
That implies an effective vessel-CAPEX support rate of ~51%, not 80%. At that
rate, the modelled required carbon price for Europe at 2030 costs is ~$322
/tCO₂ rather than ~$540 /tCO₂ without support.
Overall, CRU’s modelling framework shows that targeted grants can be
decisive for individual investments and can impactfully reduce the required
incentive for capital-intensive pathways. However, they are less effective
where recurring fuel expenditure is the principal barrier. This leaves green
ammonia and e-Methanol at the high-cost end of the curve even under a generous support
test.We will explore the impact of OPEX subsidies on shipping abatement and
freight costs in a future insight.
A full data pack of model results,
including the CAPEX-support sensitivity, covering the period 2024–2050 is
available to Premium subscribers of the CRU Energy Transition and
Decarbonisation Service. The datapack also includes real-world policy
test-cases. If you want to know more about our work on abatement costs and
process emissions, contact us, we’ll be happy to talk.