Tankers remain the
principal engine, but what makes the current market increasingly remarkable is
how many other shipping sectors are simultaneously running at, or close to,
historically exceptional levels.
Average VLCC earnings climbed another 10% this past week to around
$660,000 a day, while suezmax earnings surged 72% to a record $630,000. Clean
MR earnings rose 30% to $64,000, double levels at the start of September. VLGCs chalked up another record too, with
US Gulf-Japan earnings nearing $194,000 a day, while one-year charter rates for
a 6,500 ceu car carrier have hit $95,000, the highest level outside the 2022-24
boom. Bulker earnings eased during
China’s Golden Week but remain firm at a weighted $23,062 a day. Containership
charter rates are holding at elevated levels amid scarce availability, while
even LNG spot rates showed some improvement in Clarksons’ assessment, with
modern two-stroke tonnage at $42,250 a day.
The latest surge caps a record quarter. Clarksons calculated that the
ClarkSea Index averaged $46,384 a day during Q3, beating the previous quarterly
record of $44,222 set in the second quarter of 2008 and reaching around twice
its 10-year trend. The defining
feature of the present boom remains disruption. Clarksons estimates crude flows
through Hormuz have recovered to around 12m barrels per day from below 2m at
their Q2 low. But the logistics bear little resemblance to normal trading. A
shuttle fleet is moving oil from inside the Middle East Gulf to the Gulf of
Oman, where cargoes are transferred ship-to-ship onto other tankers for onward
delivery to Asia. Flows from Yanbu have also been rearranged, while Brazilian
crude is travelling increasingly long distances. Veson Nautical sees the same inefficiency
dividend heading into the fourth quarter. It argued in a new report that
ship-to-ship operations, Suez diversions and longer Atlantic voyages are tying
up tanker capacity faster than the loss of Middle Eastern barrels is reducing
cargo demand. Veson does not expect full restoration of Middle East oil flows
before at least mid-2027. The
risk is that today’s freight bonanza is triggering an enormous supply response.
Veson counts 198 VLCCs ordered so far this year, compared with 89 in the whole
of 2025, taking the VLCC orderbook-to-fleet ratio to 37%. Five-year-old VLCC
values are up 70% this year.
Clarksons’ numbers are even more eye-catching on asset values, assessing
a five-year-old VLCC at $215m against $131m for a newbuilding, while a
15-year-old vessel is now valued at $160m.
The same supply question hangs over other booming sectors. Veson
forecasts bulker demand growing around 2.6% annually through 2029 against fleet
supply growth of 3.8%, albeit with Simandou providing important long-haul
tonne-mile support. Containers face a
larger imbalance. The orderbook has topped 14m teu, with net fleet growth
forecast to average 10.9% annually between 2026 and 2029 against teu-mile
demand growth of around 4.1%. Veson consequently forecasts freight rates
declining by roughly 32% over the period.
The freight market is, however,
starting to turn. Xeneta chief analyst Peter Sand said transpacific spot rates
edged higher again on October 1 but believes the post-Hormuz peak has now been
reached. Far East-US west coast rates remain 344% above their February 28
level, while east coast rates are up 335%.
“Demand is not strong and rates have now peaked, but they will not
collapse,” Sand said, forecasting elevated freight costs through the remainder
of the year. Xeneta puts current Far East-US west coast spot rates at $8,346
per feu and east coast rates at $11,523.
Dry bulk asset markets are displaying their own signs of exuberance. MB
Shipbrokers assesses kamsarmax resales at $41m against $38m for a newbuilding,
while a prompt newcastlemax resale is worth $92m compared with $78m for a new
order. Across shipping, the ordering
response is becoming enormous. Clarksons says 71m cgt has been contracted this
year, running in line with the record-breaking pace of 2007. The global
orderbook has reached an all-time high of 226m cgt, up 25% year on year.
Shipyard output could hit new records of 64m cgt in 2027 and 69m cgt in 2028,
with global fleet growth accelerating towards 6% annually. There is another ceiling beginning to
emerge: what charterers can afford. Poten & Partners calculates that moving
Middle Eastern crude to Asia by VLCC cost just $1.73 per barrel in January,
around 3% of the delivered crude price. At today’s extraordinary tanker rates,
it puts freight at almost $33 per barrel, equivalent to 27% of the delivered
cost. That is beginning to influence which crude refiners buy and could
ultimately force some to cut runs if margins disappear. Poten’s conclusion is
that tanker rates should remain strong while crude demand exceeds supply; once
the oil market loosens, however, the freight market could cool rapidly. Clarksons comes to a similar crossroads.
Its short-term outlook remains “very strong”, dominated by the exceptional
crude tanker market and Middle East disruption. Longer term, however,
calculating how much shipping the world will require is becoming increasingly
“tricky” as geopolitics collides with rapidly accelerating fleet growth.
The industry,
Clarksons concluded, is sitting on an exceptional cash position — but also
faces significant risk ahead.